What a terrific book! One of my top nine reads of 2020.

There’s a lot of literary game-playing in Graeme Macrae Burnet’s His Bloody Project: a confession, newspaper excerpts, medical reports, a travelogue, witness statements, footnotes, and a preface from the compiler - all related to the circumstances around three brutal murders committed by 17-year-old Roderick Macrae in Culduie, Scotland, 1869.

Roderick’s slow-burning account of his bloody crimes is humble and eloquent, logical and dispassionate - attributes which cast doubt on the authenticity and provenance of his statement. This is a book about the presentation and manipulation of evidence, the root causes of criminal behaviour, the development of criminal studies, and what it means to act out of character. It’s also a book about our appetite for dreadful acts, the glamour of murderers, and the entertainment we take in the judicial spectacle.

Be warned: you enter this book as a reader, but are quickly recast as judge amid the persuasive, contradictory statements. The shock moment is so softly played, so understated, it left me winded.

Borrowing the words of James Philby reporting on these brutal murders, this is “excellent entertainment.”

Finally: Carmina Smoke - what a name!

WHAT TO READ NEXT

The Accident on the A35 by Graeme Macrae Burnet

Case Study by Graeme Macrae Burnet